Former Pageant Title Holders
Mrs. New York America
1977 Susie Michaelsen
1978 Dana Meyer
1979 Mary Hulbert-Halas
1980 Marlene Moss
1981 Arlene Gibbons
1982 Janet Horvath
1983 Barbara Schantz
1984 Cynthia Fratianni
1985 Sheri Morganti
1986 Vonabell Sherman
1987 Mickey Macar
1988 Jennifer Migliore
1989 Patricia Sauer
1990 Elizabeth Van Arthos
1991 Sheila Strassburg
1992 Stacy Mesler-Prescott
1993 Cynthia Fishman
1994 Susan Bellini
1995 Diana DeSantis
* – winner of Mrs. America
** – winner of Mrs. World
1996 Jeanne DiNardo Vito
1997 Lisa Lilienthal*Mrs. America 1997
1998 Beth Bender
1999 Rebecca A. Alamprese
2000 Kathy Kaspak
2001 Christine Countryman
2002 Lisa Cove
2003 Melissa Holthoff-Briscoe
2004 Lauren Wanger-Hernandez
2005 Stephanie Tsarsi
2006 Lidia Szczepanowski-Goldsmith
2007 Shana Jaycox
2008 Kerry Lyn Boettcher
2009 Nicole Martin
2010 Meaghan Jarensky Barakett
2011 Karen O’Hara
2012 Leah Bartos
2013 Hysha Robinson Nesmith
2014 Melissa Ann Luiso
2015 Jessica Lahr
2016 Alison Trenk
2017 Alice Lee Gianetta **Mrs. World 2018
2018 Patti Gomez
2019 Kate Schneider **Mrs. World 2019
2020 Yasmeen Gumbs-Breakenridge
2021 Jessica Fabus Cheng
2022 Bethany Stevens
2023 Chloe Rosen
2024 Kathy Lovett-McKeever
2025 Christina Fanitzi
Mrs. New York American
Miss New York for America Strong
2020 Marjorie Vail
2021 Diana Meyer
2022 Kate Boydston
2023 Amanda Richie Terzian
2024 Victoria Wejko
2019 Emily Mahana
2020 Gabrielle Wright
2021 Nicole Doz
2022 Danielle Jones
2023 Victoria Treadwell
2024 Candace Taylor
2025 Rachelle Clavin